Ontario Wind Turbines
Ontario has the most expensive electricity in North America
leading to unaffordable hydro bills, manufacturing leaving, high unemployment and a stagnant economy.
This is the result of over-priced wind power; an industry Ontario doesn’t need and can’t afford.
(Compared to the provinces and the continental U.S.)
“Ontario is probably the worst electricity market in the world,”
Pierre-Olivier Pineau, Associate Professor and Electricity Market Expert, University of Montreal HEC Business School.
Ontario’s Energy Policy affects every person in Ontario.
Eleven years ago, Ontario had a vibrant energy sector. It has changed since then.
The following is a summary of the energy policy that is being implemented by the Ontario Government.
All supporting information is under Sources.
Over the next 20 years, your household will pay an additional $40,000 for electricity.
The cost of wind power will add $110,000,000,000.00 to our electrical bills.
To appreciate the cost, $100 billion can buy 5,000,000 Honda Civics.
Ontario is building 6736 Wind Turbines.
We already have clean and excess power from water, nuclear and gas.
We pay more for wind power than any province/state in North America.
We are subsidizing the wind industry.
Ontario pays 11-13.5 cents per kwh for wind power.
The average price in the U.S. is 7 cents.
The average price for Ontario nuclear, water and gas is 7 cents.
That debt charge on your hydro bill was paid off in 2010.
The 10% clean energy rebate on your hydro bill is charged to Ontario tax payers.
Ontario is the only province/state that charges HST, delivery, and regulatory fees on electricity.
Your rates increase every May and October
(Also increased in November, 2014 to pay for the $2billion loss in October)
In 2007, you paid 7 cents per kwh.
In 2015, you pay 14-27 cents per kwh, depending on usage and location.
Check your hydro bill; divide the total (including HST, delivery and regulatory fees) by your usage.
Compare our rates to: 5.6 cents in Quebec and 7.3 cents in Manitoba.
Charts comparisons of electricity rates across Canada or N. America are misleading because they do not include
Ontario’s delivery and regulatory charges.
These charges need to be included to get the actual cost.
Pro-wind groups want you to believe that our expensive electricity is from nuclear power.
However, the Ontario Power Generation states otherwise as per the link below:
Hydro Rates by Province for 1000 kWh (April 2015)
Basic monthly charge, 0.16640 per day ($4.92 monthly)
Energy Charge: 7.52¢/kWhx1000, $75.20
Rate Rider 5% Rate Rider applied to all charges before taxes and levies 4.92+75.2= 80.12 + $4 (rate rider)
Basic Monthly Charge $20.22
Energy Charge: 12.346¢/kWhx1000, $123.46 $20.22 + $123.46
Basic monthly Charge, $7.28
Energy Charge: 7.381¢/kWhx1000, $73.81 $7.28 + $73.81
20% on peak hours, 20% on mid peak, 60% on low peak is the average
200 kWh peak,$28, 200 mid, $22.8, 600 low, $42,
Total $92.80 line loss charge +$11.19
Basic Monthly Charge + $24.07
Smart meter entity charge + $0.79
Debt retirement + $7
regulatory charge + $5.95 delivery Charge (distribution charge, $33.90, + transmission connection,+ $4.99, + transmission network + $7.19, + smart meter entity charge, 25 cents) = Total $46.33
Add 13% HST = $24.46
Total = $212.59
Basic Monthly Charge, $12.19
Energy Charge: 5.57¢/kWhx1000, $55.70 55.70+12.19
Basic Monthly Charge, $22.46
Energy Charge: 10.25 ¢/kWhx1000, 102.50 102.50 + 22.46
Basic Monthly Charge, $18.82
Energy Charge: break down 20 peak/20 mid/60 low
Peak=19.305¢/kWh, Medium=14.947¢/kWh, low=8.020¢/kWh
Peak =38.60 medium= 29.89 low=48.12 38.60+29.89+48.12+18.82=135.43
Basic charge, $15.68
Energy Charge: 11.178¢/kWhx1000, $111.78 15.68+111.78
Basic Monthly Charge, $22.46
Energy Rate Charge=10.25¢/kWhx1000, $102.50 $22.46+$102.50
Manufacturing is leaving Ontario.
“Ontario has the highest industrial rates in North America.”
Association of Major Power Consumers in Ontario. Refer to Sources for complete report.
Caterpillar (2 plants), United Steel. Heinz, Bicks, International Trucking,
General Motors, Navistar, Kellogg’s, John Deer, Lance Bakeries, Kraft Foods, Unilever.
NOVA Chemicals says the cost of power is critical in its decision to locate a multi-billion-dollar polyethylene expansion in Sarnia Ontario.
Their alternative is the U.S. Gulf Coast where rates are a fraction of ours.
Since 2006, power demand has decreased by 6%.
Ontario has almost 1 million people out of work.
Ontario’s near $300 billion debt is the worst in North America.
“Ontario’s economy has not performed on par with the rest of Canada,
due in part to its slow economic growth and spiralling public debt.”
Fraser Institute, April 2014. Refer to Sources for complete report.
Gone are the days of beautiful Ontario….
“These wind projects will change this place more totally, more rapidly and more permanently
than anything in the past 10,000 years”
James Corcoran, South Huron, Ontario
30 years experience, environmental assessments on behalf of developers.
The Human & Environmental Impact
To appreciate the full impact of turbines on our people, please find the time to read this:
Pay a lower tax rate than other corporations.
Have farmers who sign lease contracts, sign a gag order.
Are exempted from municipal bylaws, building permits, proximity to highways, drainage issues.
Have weight restrictions on roads and bridges lifted during construction of wind projects.
May destroy protected wetlands.
May cause death or harm to endangered species.
Are exempt from the $10,000 fine in the event of destroying an eagle’s nest.
Override the Heritage Act.
Wind companies sue municipalities/persons who get in their way.
The government supplies lawyers to back a wind company;
but has never backed a municipality, group or person.
Municipalities have had all rights removed regarding wind projects.
Over 80 municipalities are “unwilling hosts” to turbines, but are not acknowledged.
July, 2014. MPP Jeff Yurek asked the Premier whether she will listen to constituents in
West Elgin and Dutton who have stated they do not want industrial wind turbine development.
This was her response:
Every turbine destroys 3 acres of land; roughly 21,000 acres of farmland lost forever.
Ontario turbines are closer to people than any place in the world.
Turbine neighbours suffer from turbine noise and wind turbine syndrome which can be life threatening.
Residents are abandoning their homes at a unprecedented pace.
The fortunate are bought out by the wind companies, but must sign a gag order.
Rural Ontario areas are becoming ghost towns.
People call turbines bird blenders because they slice, maim and slaughter birds.
Turbines will be built in the precise paths of the millions of birds that migrate to or through Ontario.
Turbines kill more bats than birds (their lungs explode from the turbine’s drop in air pressure).
Don’t neglect the importance of bats to our eco-system.
Worms are absent around turbines. (it is thought to be from the vibration in the ground).
Farms need the three types of worms to keep the land fertile for crops. No worms, no crops.
A Perspective of Turbine Height
Using the Absolute Towers in Mississauga rendered in as a backdrop:
Absolute Towers is 56 storeys.
The small turbine is the CNE turbine – 299 feet high.
The mid-size is the average Ontario turbine - 380 feet high.
The tall one is the new Ontario turbine - 550 feet and taller.
The rendering below provides a perspective of Ontario’s new turbines.
The building behind is 38 storeys.
Ontario’s wind energy policy is convoluted and wastes money.
- Nuclear, hydro, & gas is clean, cheap and has a 100% reliability, but, wind is given priority to our grid.
- Wind power is expensive and unreliable; available 20-30% of the time.
- When there is no wind, there is no wind power available.
- For every kwh of wind power, we need one kwh of backup, that could otherwise be used as our sole source.
- Ontario is spending $11 billion building transmission lines to feed power from every wind project.
That’s an additional $2750 cost to your household
- Ontario has too much power and we either, pay the USA & Quebec to get rid of the excess or charge 2.5 per kwh.
From 2005 to 2012, the loss was $1.8 billion which cost your household an extra $450.
In 2013, the loss was $1 billion which will cost your household an additional $250.
In October 2014 alone, Ontario paid $1 billion over market price for energy resulting in an immediate increase in hydro rates,
- Quebec turns around and sells our hydro at 5 cents per kwh to bordering States.
- When there is too much power, Ontario pays $1 million dollars a day to take a nuclear plant off-line ($66 million in 2013)
and pays wind companies to shut down their turbines.
- $6 billion was spent to increase the power at Niagara Falls; only to divert the water when there is excess power.
- Ontario pays gas plants to run as backup for wind power.
- The first weekend in August, Ontario lost $10 million because of highly windy days resulting in unexpected power to the grid.
The same occurred on November 9 & 10, where Ontario lost another $20 million.
- September 11, 2013: Ontario agreed to pay Wind Energy companies $200,000 per mw not to supply power,
The government says it’s “cheaper than paying the USA & Quebec to use it”.
Since then, new wind projects continue to be approved.
- The plan to build two new nuclear reactors at Darlington was abruptly cancelled in October 2013 at a cost of $180 million.
- During the 2011 election, the Liberals cancelled the construction of 2 gas plants to win Liberal seats.
These cancellations totaled $1.1 billion which will cost your household an additional $250.
- The Lambton coal plant had just been upgraded at a cost of $1 billion to produce clean coal before it was closed in October 2013.
That will cost your household another $250.
Ironically, the Lambton coal plant is 1 km from a coal plant in Michigan that is still active.
“This situation is expected to get much worse over the next several years as significant amounts of wind,
hydraulic and nuclear generation will be coming into service while expected electrical demand will continue
to be stagnant.”
Ontario Society of Professional Engineers. Refer to Sources for complete report
Truth is stranger than fiction
Ontario pays 11-13.5 cents for wind power.
Ontario pays or charges Quebec 2.5 cents take our excess.
The loss is subsidized by Ontario consumers.
Quebec sells it to border States for 5 cents.
Manufacturers can move to the States and get cheap power; where a portion is sourced from Ontario and subsidized by Ontario consumers.
New York State sees an opportunity.
Promotional information was sent to Ontario’s Manufacturing sector citing Ontario’s high energy costs as a good reason to relocate to New York State. http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/politics/soaring-energy-prices-making-ontario-look-dim-for-manufacturers/article17560172/
Wolfe Island – actual photo
The Vulnerability of our Grid
- When produced, power has to be used immediately; there’s no technology to store it for a later time.
- There is excess power almost every hour of every day, and Ontario scrambles to find a state/province that will take it.
- Depending on their power needs at the time, we either give it away (spill it), pay to take it (spill it) or charge a very low rate.
- Because wind power is so unpredictable, the IESO staff are continually manipulating the grid; telling the nuclear, gas and hydro suppliers to adjust their output accordingly; and the excess is then sent to Quebec, Manitoba and the States.
According to the Ontario Society of Professional Engineers:
Carbon Dioxide Emissions will increase by 48% in 2030,
because gas plants constantly starting up and shutting down expel more emissions than if they ran continually.
Much of our wind power will go to Quebec and the States.
Wind blows mostly at night and in the winter when we need power the least.
There is no wind on a hot summer day, when our air conditioners need it the most.
Constant changes to the grid are prone to error and Ontario’s grid wasn’t built to handle such.
Be prepared for frequent and long blackouts or worse, as in complete failure of our energy grid.
Ontario has more than enough power with Nuclear, Hydro (water) and Gas.
Ontario’s average demand for power is roughly 18,000 mw.
In the last 8 years, Ontario’s highest demand for power was 27,005 mw on August 1, 2006.
The amount of available reliable power is 30,806 mw which far exceeds the demand.
Nuclear = 12947 mw: Hydro = 7939 mw; Gas = 9920 mw.
The Liberals will have added 3725 mw of installed wind energy by the end of 2014;
January 2015, the Liberals announced that they are adding an additional 300 mw to the grid in 2016;
With intentions of adding more.
“Ontario will phase in wind, solar and bioenergy
….with 10,700 MW online by 2021.”
Ministry of Energy
Wind in Ontario’s Sails as Renewables Fuel $2 Billion in Project Spending for Fourth-Quarter 2014
September 19, 2014 from Stockhouse.com
“Ontario’s ambitious renewable energy goals are making the Canadian province a top destination for wind and solar power developers. Across all industries, Industrial Info is tracking $2 billion in active projects that are set to kick off in Ontario in fourth-quarter 2014, with wind and solar way ahead of the pack.”
A side note: Ontario is also using Biomass energy
Ontario is offering 44-88 cents per kwh for bioenergy
The role of trees and forests in our ecosystems is absolutely critical.
A single tree can absorb 10 pounds of air pollutants a year, and produce nearly 260 pounds of oxygen; enough to support two people.
Forests and woodlots are being cleared Ontario, where trees are trucked to incinerators (up to 500 km in distance), to be burned for energy fuel.
As an example, Google Atikokan.
The Driving Force
”The province’s wind and solar power initiatives were decided and implemented in such haste
that “no comprehensive business-case evaluation was done to objectively evaluate the impacts
of the billion-dollar commitment.”
Auditor General of Ontario
The Liberals introduced and passed the Green Energy Act 2009.
The NDP have supported the Liberals on wind energy since its inception.
The PC’s do not support subsidized wind power.
The key person behind Ontario’s move to Wind Energy is Gerald Butts.
Butts was Principal Secretary to Premier McGuinty where he was intimately involved in the government’s environmental initiatives.
On February 6, 2014, to address the rising cost of energy, Butts and Energy Minister Chiarelli introduced National Sweater Day.
Butts is currently the chief environmental advisor to Federal Liberal leader, Justin Trudeau.
The Green Energey Act was developed by (then) Energy Minister George Smitherman with direction from the Canadian Wind Energy Association.
Members of the Liberal party are profiting from Ontario’s wind energy.
In 2004, Mike Crawley, the (then) President for the Ontario Liberals,
was awarded a wind power contract that guarantees his company $66,000 a day for a total of $1/2 Billion dollars.
Since then, Crawley has been awarded additional Wind Project contracts.
Crawley is currently President of the Federal Liberal Party.
There are now about 50 resident wind lobbyists in Toronto.
The Wind Industry held a fundraising event for Kathleen Wynne in April 2013.
Those who promote Wind power, benefit financially by doing so.
David Suzuki, Pembina Institute, Cleantech, MaRs, Environmental Defence,
Friends of the Wind, Windfacts and CANWEA.
A wind company is getting a pass on violating the law?
In the Niagara region, four turbines that were built too close to residents, are violating the law and need to be dismantled.
The Minister of Energy has done nothing.
Every project could be stopped today; if the Liberals want to.
The Ontario Government has the discretionary power to cancel or modify these contracts but it’s clear they don’t want to.
An Ontario court ruling in the decision of Trillium vs. Ontario, 2013, clearly states that:
“Governments are free to alter policies in the public interest.”
“Companies in the renewable power business participate in government subsidy programs ‘at their own risk’.”
As of March, 2014, the Liberals are continuing with the 55 incomplete wind power projects (about 4900 turbines) that could be stopped legally.
“If you are asking me, will you cancel those [wind project] contracts outright? The answer is no we won’t!”
Kathleen Wynne, in Kincardine, April 24, 2014
For ruling, refer to Discussion at the bottom of this page
Chatham Kent Airport – Location of turbines was denied by Transport Canada,
fought by the municipality, but approved by the Ontario Government.
The same is happening in Collingwood, Peterborough, Goderich, Kincardine, Huron Park, Grand Bend and the Niagara Region.
The sky-diving club in Niagara Region will have to shut down.
The Liberal’s response is shown in this video:
Energy Platform by Party
The PC’s introduced Bill 42 in 2012 and Bill 39 in 2013 to eliminate wind subsidies and give control back to municipalities.
The NDP’s and Liberals voted against these bills. Refer to Sources.
Will be pursuing additional wind power projects in 2015 and again in 2016.
Remove the Ontario Hydro Debt charge on January 1, 2016. (About $60 a year decrease in costs).
Discontinue the Clean Energy Rebate on December 31, 2015. (About $170 a year increase in costs).
Introduce a surcharge for families making over $40,000, to subsidize lower income families.
Committed to “aggressively expand renewable energy”.
Honour existing green energy contracts.
Will remove the HST on hydro bills.
Will eliminate the export of excess power, but have not provided details as to how that will be accomplished.
Place a moratorium on all renewable power projects starting in 2018.
Scrap Ontario’s wind energy policy.
Give control back to municipalities.
Put a moratorium on wind energy projects.
Eliminate wind subsidies, which would substantially reduce our hydro bills.
“We propose scrapping the Green Energy Act and implementing an immediate moratorium
on industrial wind turbines until the jury is in on health and environmental studies.
We will not sign any more FIT contracts and will take a look at the existing ones.”
PC MPP Toby Barrett, April 2, 2014
Wolfe Island before & after the Liberal’s energy policies
Is Nothing Sacred?
Near Peterborough, a $40 million project to build the largest Buddhist complex outside of China is in jeopardy.
The Liberals knowingly approved wind turbines to surround the complex.
The people in charge of the development say these turbines will have a negative impact on the serenity of the complex.
This complex would have attracted about 45,000 visitors a year and generated more than $20 million for Ontario.
Wind Farms slated for Ontario
Rondeau Bay – Actual photo
Wind verses Nuclear
- Nuclear power costs 6.8 cents per kwh, period.
Wind power costs 11-13.5 cents per kwh, plus all other costs mentioned above.
- One wind project approved for the area east of Grand Bend is approximately 34 km long and 16 km wide.
The nuclear footprint is 9 sq. kilometers.
- It will have 63 wind turbines with a maximum output of 102 mwh.
- Applying efficiency factor of 30%, actual output will be 30 mwh.
- Ontario average usage is 18,000 mwh.
- Nuclear can provide approximately 12,947 mwh 24/7.
- This wind project has the potential of providing .16% (1/6th of one percent) our energy needs.
- When there is no wind, it will provide 0% of our energy needs.
In 10-20 years
- The Niagara Falls hydro generating stations are 100 years old, but wind turbines are good for only 10-20 years.
- Each turbine construction consists of 800 tonnes of cement for support, approximately 250 tonnes of unrecyclable materials, 700 litres of hydraulic fuel and, 600 kilograms of rare earth metals. Multiply these numbers by 6736 and Ontario is facing a potential ecological conundrum.
- The are no bonds posted to ensure these turbines will be dismantled at the end of their life cycle. It is estimated that a turbine, depending on size, will cost $400,000 to $1,000,000 to dismantle.
- Given that wind companies are predominantly foreign, change ownership or, go bankrupt, it is quite realistic to expect 100′s or 1,000′s of dead turbines in 20 years and left standing.
- This is happening already. Wind Companies usually don’t fix or dismantle broken turbines and, Ontario already has many non-functioning turbines.
If companies won’t dismantle a couple of turbines now; what about the future ones?.
- The Liberals have no plans as to where to dispose these materials, nor have indicated that wind companies will be responsible for the costs of building the landfill sites or depots.
- One can only assume, that the cost to dispose 6736 turbines will be covered by the people of Ontario.
In 10-20 years, we could be faced with a landscape of old, rusted out, broken down turbines.
For the record:
This site is not anti-wind energy, but attempts to convey its path of implementation in Ontario.
Wind energy has seen success in areas such Nevada, Texas, Kansas, Arizona, Wyoming, Alberta, and Quebec to name a few.
The success was the result of comprehensive studies and business plans; turbines built where wind speeds are high;
turbines built away from the popluation; and, promotion of competition to get the cheapest rates.
Ontario did none of this.
The Canadian Taxpayers Federation:
Launched a petition to dismantle the Liberal Green Energy Act.
282,001 total views since March 11 2014